New Jersey Joins $183.5 Million Acima Settlement Over Rent-to-Own Practices

The multistate agreement includes consumer restitution and lease-balance forgiveness. Acima says the settlement contains no findings or admissions of wrongdoing.

NEW JERSEY — New Jersey has joined a $183.5 million settlement with rent-to-own company Acima over allegations that its marketing, payment practices and other conduct misled consumers.

The agreement announced Nov. 12 involves 43 states. Its total includes $43 million in consumer restitution, $130 million in lease-balance forgiveness and $10.5 million for the states, according to the New Jersey attorney general’s announcement.

The announcement does not specify how much an individual New Jersey customer will receive.

Acima’s business allows customers to obtain merchandise through rental-purchase agreements. An Oregon complaint filed as part of the settlement describes a process in which Acima buys merchandise from participating retailers and leases it to consumers.

The complaint alleges that customers could misunderstand those transactions as loans or installment purchases. It also alleges that advertised 90-day purchase options required customers to take additional steps, while the minimum automatic payments generally followed a longer schedule that could make the total cost at least twice the merchandise’s cash price.

Those are allegations, not findings after a trial.

In a company statement distributed by Business Wire, Acima said the agreement resolves a multistate investigation dating to 2021 and includes no findings or admissions of wrongdoing.

The company confirmed a $53.5 million payment and $130 million in forgiveness involving charged-off accounts of certain customers who retained merchandise after default. It said the payment had been reserved in parent company Upbound Group’s year-end 2025 financial statements.

The settlement also requires changes to Acima’s business practices. New Jersey officials described requirements addressing clearer contract disclosures, merchandise returns and credit reporting, including a five-year restriction on reporting to the three major credit bureaus.

The Oregon attorney general’s announcement describes the case as involving the difference between the price customers expected to pay and the obligations created by the rental agreements.

Eligible consumers do not need to take action now to receive relief, according to New Jersey’s announcement. A settlement administrator will contact customers eligible for restitution, while Acima will notify customers eligible for lease forgiveness.

Leave a Comment